Saturday, May 26, 2012Cloudy 25°C
Eat & Drink

Liquid Alternatives in the Face of Looming LCBO Strike

Posted by Derek Flack / June 24, 2009

LCBO StrikeInsofar as I often occupy the knife's edge between wine lover and highly functioning alcoholic, news of a possible LCBO strike had my stomach all tied up in knots. And while the latest news is that negotiations will continue past yesterday's midnight strike deadline, no doubt similar - if less dramatic - fears were what led countless numbers of people to clear out liquor store shelves in anticipation of a strike.

At the Dupont and Spadina location, where I made my last minute run, the competition between bar and restaurant owners looking for some insurance stock and individuals hoping to avoid the complete depletion of their liquor cabinets was fierce. But just as my panic that my own provisions would last only a paltry few days brought on what I was convinced were pre-withdrawal shivers, I had a moment of clarity.

LCBO Strike

There's always The Beer Store. Despite my anxiety that negotiations would cease at midnight, I somehow recalled a Toronto Star article published last summer that sought to dispel the then fairly widespread myth that The Beer Store was run by the provincial government. While not usually a fan of Brewer's Retail Inc.'s monopoly of the Ontario beer market, hypocrisy was the furthest thing from my mind as I reminded myself that they would remain unaffected by the LCBO strike, if and when it took place.

But in spite of the fact that this realization quelled my initial fears, my preference for wine got me thinking of other options that might be available in the event of a strike. Surely, I told myself, you've found other ways to acquire wine over your career of drinking. Well, that was all it took. All of a sudden a flood of alternatives to the LCBO rushed into my mind. Here's a list of a few options I've come up with, most of which are pretty darn good even if - please, please, please! - the strike never becomes a reality.

The Wine Rack, Vineyard Estates, and Kittling Ridge Estates, Various Locations
Although not quite the same, I usually lump these three stores together because each one offers solely Canadian (and mostly Ontario) offerings. The main difference, however, is that only Kittling Ridge offers solely its own brand. The Wine Rack features brands like Jackson-Triggs and Inniskillin, while at Vineyard Estates I've found Peller Estates and Hillebrand amongst others. Most of these outlets are located within grocery stores.

WineOnline.ca
Having bought a few inexpensive cases from Wine Online in the past, I'd happily return as a customer in the event of a prolonged strike. The international selection of this exclusively online retailer is often exciting and always well-sourced. When I haven't wanted or been able to afford a whole case, I've group-purchased with friends. But because agents in Ontario aren't allowed to warehouse their own imported wine, and because the strike will also affect staffing at the LCBO's Specialty Services department (consignment warehouse), buying at Wine Online may be restricted to wine available from Ontario wineries during the strike. Shipping to my door has always been uber fast and cheap (often free when purchasing two or more cases).

WineryToHome.com
I have to admit that there are times when I'm unsatisfied with the options available at the previously mentioned local Ontario wine stores. Although I've yet to use their service, WinerytoHome has been recommended by more than a few of my wine-buff friends. Stocking wines from over 40 Canadian wineries, they seem to be the place to turn for VQA wines. Plus, in the event of a strike at the LCBO, they're offering free shipping on certain minimum orders. Again, any products that are stocked at the LCBO's consignment warehouse may not be available for purchase during the strike.

Niagara and/or Prince Edward County
I make a point of heading to local Ontario wineries at least a few times a year. Not only are the locales beautiful, but there's something about tasting wine in its very terroir (place of growth) that just feels (and tastes) right. I know it's not Tuscany or Chateauneuf-du-Pape, but I still love Ontario's wine county.

Duty Free
Despite the wine-centric nature of this list, I think Duty Free is one of the only options for acquiring spirits in the event of a strike. Although I might find this a touch hard to justify, that little calculator in my brain is already trying to figure out if the savings on the booze might cancel out the gas-costs. Now that I think about it, I might even do this as part of my trip to some Niagara wineries!

Agency Stores
Some tiny liquor stores that are usually attached to rural grocery stores way outside of the city (you'll have to drive pretty far to find one) are independently operated and may stay open (and will likely be depleted of stock rather quickly in the event of a strike).

The Beer Hunter
Although not a place to acquire alcohol per se, I've often used this online service to find the best places to do so when closing times are near. If the strike does happen, this is a great place to locate wine and independent brewers unaffected by it. In the event that a deal is worked out, I plan on continuing to use this map-based site to locate those beer and wine retailers that are open late into the evening.

LCBO Strike Exterior

Discussion

30 Comments

Xavier / June 24, 2009 at 07:38 am
user-pic
The wine rack offers only their own brands. All of the wines available there are Vincor products
G / June 24, 2009 at 07:50 am
user-pic
"I usually lump these three stores together because each one offers solely Canadian (and mostly Ontario) offerings"

Are you kidding me! These are mainly cellered in Canada wines containing 70% foreign wine. Stop misleading the public and support the real Ontario VQA wine industry!
The Beerad / June 24, 2009 at 08:18 am
user-pic
Agreed, it's VQA or nothing in our household. "Cellared in Canada" does not cut it.
blamblamvietnam replying to a comment from The Beerad / June 24, 2009 at 08:52 am
user-pic
I feel sorry for your family.
Johnny Awesome / June 24, 2009 at 08:55 am
user-pic
This pending strike is far more important than that "garbage" strike those other jerks are having. No way does this one make it to the weekend, even if they do strike. You think the powers that be have'nt checked the forecast for the weekend? We're Canadians. We care about our booze not about some spoiled garbage collectors!
I cant wait to throw my empties at some picketors.
David / June 24, 2009 at 09:01 am
user-pic
Good to see the cops need licker too!
rocker / June 24, 2009 at 09:03 am
user-pic
the people who need booze this badly are pathetic.
Jerrold replying to a comment from rocker / June 24, 2009 at 09:08 am
user-pic
^^ Or their livelihood depends on having wine and liquor to sell in their restaurants and bars.
Jay / June 24, 2009 at 09:15 am
user-pic
Magnotta also has a bunch of GTA locations: http://www.magnotta.com/Locations.aspx -- most just carry wine but Vaughan also has True North beer.
blamblamvietnam replying to a comment from rocker / June 24, 2009 at 09:15 am
user-pic
We also need it to tolerate puritan flunkies like you.
Buffalopundit / June 24, 2009 at 09:17 am
user-pic
You can also stop by any one of the many fine local establishments in Western New York. My favorites are the <a href="http://www.premiergroup.net/";>Premier Group</a> (locations: Milestrip in Orchard Park off the 219, Delaware & Sheridan in Tonawanda, and Transit Road in Williamsville between Sheridan and Maple). <a href="http://www.passport-ws.com/";>Passport in Clarence is new</a> and very accommodating.

Closer to Niagara Falls is Supermarket Liquors on NF Blvd at Military, not far from the Outlet Mall and Wegmans.
Johnny Awesome replying to a comment from rocker / June 24, 2009 at 09:20 am
user-pic
I think someone is off their rocker.
Duarte / June 24, 2009 at 09:37 am
user-pic
IF the LCBO does eventually go on strike WineAlign will be offering access to our premium service with detailed critics’ reviews FREE OF CHARGE during the duration of the strike. More details at www.lcbostrike.com or winealign.com
Paul replying to a comment from rocker / June 24, 2009 at 09:43 am
user-pic
Given the current state of things in Toronto I can see why everyone needs a good supply of alcohol.
Derek / June 24, 2009 at 09:46 am
user-pic
In response to some of the early comments, it's true that a lot of the wines stocked at these outlets aren't truly from Canada or Ontario. Brands like French Cross and Naked Grape fit this description. But, in all fairness, these stores do all sell VQA designated wines as well. Sure there isn't the widest of selections, but if the strike goes down, that will appear a minor issue.

Xaiver: Thanks for pointing out that The Wine Rack offers solely Vincor brands.
Wes Kibble / June 24, 2009 at 10:30 am
user-pic
I am definatly supporting the LCBO workers a lot more than the city workers that are on strike. I know a few people that work at LCBO and they have been "part time workers" for over 10 years, but work 25-35 hours a week and still only get part time benefits (which means none). Instead of making them full time employees and giving them a few more hours, they just hire more part time people. Compared to the city workers striking over not being allowed to bank their 18 sick days per year...
ian / June 24, 2009 at 10:33 am
user-pic
Liqour can still be found at bars and restaraunts (for now...). Pride weekend, Canada Day - it's not Prohibition, but that's leveraging your strike timing, eh?
Adam / June 24, 2009 at 12:08 pm
user-pic
Speaking of the LCBO - Does anyone know how much a Texas Mickey of say Vodka costs?
And does the LCBO simply sell them in-store or do would I have to order one?
Im thinking on getting each of my groomsmen one and was just curious as to what they cost.
Any help would be great!!
Natalie MacLean / June 24, 2009 at 12:48 pm
user-pic
I'm offering a FREE newsletter & shopping list of tasty LCBO wines > $20 here to help stock up now: www.nataliemaclean.com/winepicks
Reality Check / June 24, 2009 at 01:07 pm
user-pic
@Adam - Texas mickeys are available at some locations - best bets are Summerhill and Port Carling, or other high income hard partying locations. Liberty Village LCBO had one 1.5L bottle of Grey Goose yesterday and then the vodka selection dropped down to Prince Igor...

This just highlights why unionized monopolies are horrible. Screws the customers AND screws the employees - LCBO is operated on a province wide standard instead of each neighbourhood having their own stores. We should have stores in certain neighbourhoods that provide great careers for wine aficionados and others that are normal retail offerings. Of course thanks to the union all LCBO workers are horribly overpaid and don't do anywhere near as many hours as they get paid for. FIRE THEM ALL.
Tim replying to a comment from rocker / June 24, 2009 at 01:47 pm
user-pic
you just don't know how to party
Hoopie / June 24, 2009 at 02:36 pm
user-pic
Can someone grab me a 40oz of Crown if there going to the LCBO today?
i wanna be an adult / June 24, 2009 at 05:10 pm
user-pic
well my thinking is this...

why do we still live in this state of having only the "liquor store" and the "beer store" as a means to purchasing our spirits...it really seems childish...i can't help thinking fisher-price...in europe, and most, if not all of the united states, wine and beer (if not some liquor) is available in grocery stores...

i say let's make a move towards that sort of society where we can feel respected as adults and also more importantly foster smaller local businesses which will carry particular wines, beers and spirits...

let's be honest...

the lcbo does not have the best selection...if you have bought wine in quebec at SAQ you will know that we are absolutely being screwed when it comes to choice...

as consumers choice is king...i would like to have a choice...i don't need to be king...but i would like a choice...

peace...
Justin / June 24, 2009 at 05:27 pm
user-pic
everything is better with a big bag of weed.
Reality Check / June 24, 2009 at 05:54 pm
user-pic
@ i wanna - SAQ and LCBO just serve different customers but have similar problems. Depending on the product you can be happier/better served in either province - both monopolies stock based on stereotypical preferences (which in their case are just good business sense... not too many people are looking for good sctoch in Quebec City, while nearly any random LCBO in the middle of nowhere will have a VERY good scotch selection). The good thing is that you can get decent service from grocery stores and depanneurs in Quebec, which we don't get here, for beer and wine.

LCBO's selection is bad and like only being able to buy food at McDonald's - they design for the lowest common denominator. Summerhill is the best store in the province (also the biggest) but they have to turn over nearly all their inventory every two weeks in Vintages. General list is set for the entire province, irrespective of local preferences.

The huge problem is that there are only a very few good LCBOs. In a city like Toronto there should be many superb stores selling wine - Greek specialists on the Danforth, Italians on College, Rosedale served by specialists with absurdly large cellars (Le Select level). London's wine market (with amazing stores like Berry Bros & Rudd) should be our template - grocery and convenience stores serve a general market with what's usually available in a typical LCBO. Specialist stores stock what they want, with a predictable product (so very unlike our few decent LCBOs).

Big problems with our current system include the case minimum for ordering through distributors, storage ban for distributors, inability to get aged wine... So many to be honest.
meenu / June 24, 2009 at 06:36 pm
user-pic
how much do you think they guy in the denim rakes in in a day/week?
i don't think i have ever been there and he hasn't. haven't given him a dime, either.
Realist (mostly) / June 24, 2009 at 07:39 pm
user-pic
I don't think most people would disagree that the LCBO is basically bad at what it does. There are things that the government--or a government-sponsored monopoly--does well, but selling products of any sort to consumers is not among them.

Case in point: I was in Columbus, Ohio, over Christmas last year. I'm a beer drinker. Target had a better selection of beer than nearly all of the LCBOs and Beer Stores I've been to.
Canadian in Australia / June 25, 2009 at 05:05 am
user-pic
Am I sure glad I emigrated from Ontario to Australia a few years ago. Alcohol is treated far more maturely here, as the liquor laws weren't written by prudish North Americans. You can buy alcohol at hundreds of different types of stores. Even better, casual workers wouldn't need to strike, as they get full rights to vacation etc.

Oh, and there is no winter here, as added bonus.
Me in NYC replying to a comment from Canadian in Australia / June 25, 2009 at 08:29 am
user-pic
LCBO stores are nice, clean, easy to navigate. But the statement that they have better selection. Selection abounds down here in New York; there are wine shops and boutiques, microbreweries in Brooklyn, and even the lowest rent store has a varied selection that matches and in some cases surpasses anything I could find at the LCBO. A friend from TO visited a couple months back and she couldn't believe the selection.
Rabbit / June 25, 2009 at 08:46 am
user-pic
@EVERYONE WHO POSTED - So many conflicting posts here. Is EVERYONE saying that every other country in the world has a better system for the sale of liquor/win/beer? Because its really hard to tell if thats the point everyone is trying to make here. Please be more specific and direct next time.

Its booze people. Yes, it would be just terrific to have all the different selections possible. But it aint changing and there is no chance in hell any Canadian is going to stop buying booze or boycott, etc just to make a point. We'd rather see a hockey team in Phoenix before we did that. So EVERYONE please - this weekend go to your nearest LCBO (thats how you avert a strike by the way, useless CUPE workers) pick up your favorite bottle of something, sit on your patio, raise a glass in the name of booze and have fun and stop with the bellyaching.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal