Monday, February 13, 2012Partly Cloudy 2°C
Eat & Drink

The best of the Benedicts: 2006

Posted by Matt / January 13, 2007

20070113_meggies.jpg

OK, this will probably be the last "best of the year" list you'll read for 2006, so thank your lucky stars I'm a procrastinator. Over on my own blog, I run a non-regular feature called the Benedict Chronicles, largely because a few years ago I began ordering eggs benedict at every restaurant I visited that offered it. Now, since it's a new year - and it's the weekend - and because I've amassed such a wealth of knowledge on the subject - I'm going to tell you where to get the best bennies in the city.

Health warning: the components of a typical eggs benedict will contain no less than 4 eggs and about half a stick of butter. That's why they taste so good. It ain't rocket science.

The best eggs benedict I had in 2006 was:

Meggie's - 174 Eglinton Ave. W.

This gets a bit incestuous because I only went to Meggie's in the first place because I woke up on one of my rare days off, wanted an eggs benedict for breakfast, and Googled "Toronto eggs benedict" and came up with this post by blogTO's own Michelle. No need to tread over old ground, then, but Michelle was right: this is a freaking spectacular eggs benedict. One look at the gravy boat full of hollandaise sauce and I was hooked. I'm a do-it-yourselfer at heart and the ability to add the finishing touches to my own benedict by way of dribbling golden hollandaise all over the perfectly-poached eggs was an exercise in heavenly excess.

Meggie's puts a lot of store in their garlic fries, and these, too, did not disappoint. An outstanding complement to an outstanding meal all around, at $10.25 the Meggie's eggs benedict is worth every last penny.

Runners up include:

The Homeway - 955 Mt. Pleasant Rd.

This tiny little place at Mt. Pleasant and Erskine just got a Restaurant Makeover and it's pretty spectacular inside. Better yet, the food is really solid; my only complaint was that the portions are a bit small. But maybe that's a good thing in these fat-increasing days.

Eggs benedict at the Homeway is in fact called "Sinful Eggs Benedict," runs eleven bucks, and comes with spectacular home fries. The Homeway also serves Mennonite ham, whose difference from normal ham could not be explained clearly enough for me to understand it, but was nevertheless very tasty.

The Tulip - 1610 Queen St. E.

Like everything at the Tulip, the eggs benedict is greasy as hell. Sometimes, though, that's exactly what you want, particularly on a hangover morning: something so saturated with grease that it doesn't even take much effort to cut or chew. Such it is with the Tulip's benny.

Benedict at the Tulip comes ladled with a generous portion of hollandaise, which is fine by me but may not be for everybody. The home fries are rough-and-tumble chunks of fried potato with no artifice or presentation whatsoever, which - again - goes with the milieu.

Served up quick (if you can get a waiter's attention after waiting fifteen minutes just to get through the door on a busy Saturday morning), the Tulip's benedict is nasty fun.

It's a strange thing, pursuing these lakes of hollandaise, egg, and peameal bacon all over the city and the world - and it causes my mother to go into paroxysms of grief - but as long as there are still eggs benedict out there untried, the adventure continues.


The Benedict Chronicles unfolds non-regularly over on my blog, each and every time I scarf down a benedict anywhere in the world.

Discussion

8 Comments

Owen / January 13, 2007 at 02:41 pm
user-pic
ahhh no, What about Sneaky's? I will be honest, I haven't tried any of the ones above, but may do so now :) Keep on loving the eggs benedict.
sass / January 13, 2007 at 02:50 pm
user-pic
Have you tried Pear Tree in Cabbagetown? They have some tasty eggs benny...and about four different variations on the classic kind.
Matt / January 13, 2007 at 04:39 pm
user-pic
Hi Owen and Sass, I have tried neither, and both shall now be added to the list! Thanks.
Jerrold / January 14, 2007 at 12:34 am
user-pic
Le Petit Dejeuner does the benny with a twist of lemon - fabulous!

And this morning I had Cora's brie and mushroom version - incredible!

I'll also vouch for Pear Tree's.
Dave / January 14, 2007 at 04:58 pm
user-pic
I'd recommend BY the Way Cafe on Bloor, although it can be a bit pricey. The eggs benedict are worth the coin coughage, though.
sookie / January 15, 2007 at 10:37 am
user-pic
I'm with you Matt, I love my Eggs and Hollandaise, and try it everywhere I go. Recently we convinced the owner of a little no-frills cafe called The Lunchbox (Keele and Bloor) to start making it on weekends (until 2:30) and it's got to be the best I've had in the city. I get mine with roasted tomato and it's delicious. I've still gotta get out and try Petit Dejeuner and Mildred Pierce - from what I've heard they're the top two.
Jeremy Wilson / January 15, 2007 at 03:39 pm
user-pic
Hello Toast at the corner of Pape and Queen has the best Eggs Benedict I've had in Toronto.
mainja / January 20, 2007 at 10:00 pm
user-pic
although it's not fancy in any way, i find myself partial to the eggs benny at Johnny G's (on Parliament).

it's not for the faint of heart (literally i suppose) because it's 3 poached eggs and a generous dousing of hollandaise. you can get it with fries, home fries or salad. usually i opt for the salad so that i can feel ever so slightly less guilty, but honestly, there is nothing quite like fries dipped in hollandaise...

it comes with coffee and juice, and unfortunatly i can't remember the price, but i'm thinking it runs in around the $7.50 mark.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal