Thursday, June 20, 2013Clear 15°C
City

6 Toronto mayors who behaved badly before Ford

Posted by Mariam Matti / September 9, 2012

Rob FordAlthough Rob Ford makes headlines for his questionable behaviour more often than his constituents might like, if you look over Toronto's history since its incorporation back in 1834, you'll find that we've had an array of colourful characters as mayors over the years.

There's been a murderer, a thief, a torturer, a traitor and a mayor who beat up councillors he didn't like. Let's take a quick look at some of Toronto's more colourful municipal leaders.

JOHN POWELL
A month before taking office in 1838 as Toronto's fifth mayor, John Powell shot and killed Captain Anthony Anderson. He'd been involved in suppressing William Lyon MacKenzie's rebellion of 1837. After successfully killing one of the rebels, Powell turned the gun on Toronto's first mayor, Mackenzie, but the piece jammed. Powell was (perhaps surprisingly) admired for this act of violence back then and took office shortly thereafter.

HENRY SHERWOOD
Mackenzie, seemingly always the centre of attention, also had his home broken into by another mayor. Henry Sherwood was the 7th mayor of Toronto and reportedly had 18 children. He carried out a home invasion in 1826, breaking into MacKenzie's home and newspaper offices. Along with his drunken mob, he destroyed the printing press and dumped into Toronto harbor.

SAM MCBRIDE
Imagine if Ford took a swing at Stintz during the transit debate? When Sam McBride was mayor, he was known to beat up councillors he didn't like, swatting them with council agendas.

GEORGE GURNETT
But that's not even the most extreme form of violence attributed to Toronto's political figures. Consider George Gurnett, who tortured an opposition candidate with tar-and-feathering. The victim was stripped, then had boiling tar poured all over his body. To add insult to injury, he was then rolled in chicken feathers and upon attempting to peel off the feathers afterwards, he'd inevitably peel off his own skin.

ALLAN LAMPORT
In other political malfeasances, Allan Lamport was known for his partying ways. He spent $373,000 over two years on liquor, cigars, gourmet dinners and room service in a Royal York Hotel suite, all paid for by city taxpayers. And considering it was the 1950s, that certainly wasn't considered chump change. I guess you could call Lamport the inventor of the gravy train.

GEORGE MONRO
George Monro got the job because of a sex scandal, although it had nothing to do with him (imagine if Adam Giambrone had that kind of twisted luck). The previous mayor, John Powell (the same one who shot and killed the rebel), had put up one of his properties for sublet, to be used as a brothel. Council removed him immediately and Monro got the job by default.

A post in public office goes hand in hand with the criticism of your constituents, and rightly so if you're engaging in corruption, but back then it was a time of lawlessness. And despite all this, no mayor was ever, formally, in jeopardy of losing his title.

Photo by BruceK in the blogTO Flickr pool

Discussion

13 Comments

1train / September 9, 2012 at 12:19 pm
user-pic
Rob Ford is making Mel Lastman look not so bad. He's a disgrace brought to us by the suburbs.
Melissa / September 9, 2012 at 12:27 pm
user-pic
It's interesting to point out though that only 1 on the mayors on this list was in the past 60 or so years.. the other 5 were from almost 200 years ago. There is definitely a BIG difference in what is considered proper behaviour and decorum now than what was acceptable 200 years ago.
Bruce / September 9, 2012 at 01:59 pm
user-pic
What about Mel and his "end up in a pot" comment about Africa...racist scum.
George / September 9, 2012 at 07:39 pm
user-pic
@1train - I don't know how many times it needs to be said, but yes, even the "suburbs" are part of Toronto.

I'm not a Ford supporter but I don't live downtown and I'm not trying to defend anyone here.

However I think one GOOD thing to come out of Ford's election is that maybe its citizens are starting to realize just how big Toronto actually is and how difficult it is now and how hard it will be in the future for everyone to work together to solve all of the issues the city as a WHOLE are dealing with.
kevin replying to a comment from Bruce / September 9, 2012 at 07:51 pm
user-pic
what about ford and his "deport EVERYONE convicted of a gun crime back to their home countries" comment........racist scum.
awesome / September 9, 2012 at 07:56 pm
user-pic
I think it is awesome that Ford is being compared to a murderer and a thief... I mean he is bad, but he is closer related to one of the 3 stooges than any of these political fiascoes
iSkyscraper / September 9, 2012 at 08:44 pm
user-pic
New York has the same issue, where the inner suburbs that are formally part of the city (locally known as the "outer boroughs") constantly churn out incompetent politicians at odds with the agenda set by Manhattan. Although New York has produced city councillors far worse than Rob Ford (one of them in recent years actually shot and killed another one at city hall), New York has never had a mayor as incompetent or ridiculous (and yes, I'm including Dinkins). Even Jerry Springer was a better municipal leader when he ran Cincinnati.

I appreciate the fun concept of the post, but let's face it, Ford is by far the most inept, underskilled and underwhelming mayor of modern Toronto.
Carla / September 9, 2012 at 09:01 pm
user-pic
As bad as he's been, Ford is still a better mayor than David Miller ever was.

City Hall as dysfunctional as it is, is running better and more to the will of the people than under the control freak ideologues of the previous regime.

If you need a reminder, think garbage strike, constant fare increases for the TTC and the hiring of kids to knock on doors to see if the resident owns a cat or a dog so she can be forced to get a license for it.
LOL replying to a comment from Carla / September 9, 2012 at 09:53 pm
user-pic
You are straight coo coo for cocoa puffs!
Lee Zamparo replying to a comment from Carla / September 9, 2012 at 10:54 pm
user-pic
Your comment is hilariously petty and your memory incredibly selective. If you need a reminder of how successful Miller's administration was, think City of Toronto Act, years of surpluses, the land transfer tax. Think also a mayor that both loved the city and was competent to lead, rather than the braying moron currently in office.
Xavier replying to a comment from Lee Zamparo / September 10, 2012 at 08:36 am
user-pic
Years of surpluses? hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
You do know that Toronto's budget and debt both increased 50% under Miller right?
Karen / September 11, 2012 at 12:08 am
user-pic
Personally I am a fan of Ford, and I can't understand why everyone is so against him. He is doing exactly what he said he would when he was elected, he's cut costs where they need to be cut (over spending) and he's making smart suggestions to improve the city for the long term (something most mayors don't think about, they just try to get through their term) Its more then I can say for any other mayor of Toronto. Its councellors and everyone else in the city that are fighting his changes. Probably because he cut their salaries. Mel Lastman was a joke, and Miller was just trying to keep the rich happy, he wasn't making smart choices for the city (island airport bridge he canned would have definitely helped tourism in the city)

My best example for Ford is the light rail system that will be installed on Eglington. I live on St. Clair and I saw first hand the chaos the renovations did to the street for the street cars there, the businesses it affected/closed. The trees on the street were replaced by street lights, traffic is MUCH worse and it didn't really improve transit much at all. I would have loved to have a subway installed instead, even if it took longer and cost more. Why the hell did city counsellors vote against a subway for Eglington? My best guess, cause Ford supported it. By the time the light rail system is finished, transit volumes will require a subway which then can't be built until its then too late. The city now owns the machine that digs the subway, why not put it to use! Its cheaper then it ever was to build subways!
This is why I hate politics, its all pointless and a waste of tax payer dollars. Ford at least seems like he's trying to make a difference.
Urban Toronto / September 17, 2012 at 09:13 pm
user-pic
Mariam

It's always nice to cite the source of all your info...which is, of course:

http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/torontomayoralrace/article/745194--toronto-s-mayors-scoundrels-rogues-and-socialists

Most people don't realize that interesting and colourful Mayors of Toronto include:

A murderer: one who cold bloodedly murdered someone a month before being selected mayor (and it made him even more popular);

Mayor Goerge Gurnett, yes, actually conducted human torture;

There was a suspected tax cheat;

A mayor who took part in a home invasion;

Our friend Allan "Lampy" Lamport who, over a period of two years, spent the equivalent today of $396,000. (in today's 2012 equivalent dollars), on booze, steaks, champagne, wine, cocktails, gourmet dinners, liquor, room service, and lavish parties in a suite at the Royal York, all paid for by the city taxpayers, but with NO prior council approval, authorization, or knowledge (prompting a judicial enquiry);

A mayor who was going insane from syphilis while still in office; also jailed for three months for contempt of court;

Yes, our friend Henry Sherwood, with 18 children, he cried poor, yet died on a luxury vacation to Europe (without the kids, of course);

A mayor arrested, thrown in jail without bail for four months, stood trial for high treason; and had to flee the country and live outside Canada for years a political refugee;

A mayor for just 50 days;

The the first one to propose a subway syatem for Toronto - and yes it only took another 45 years to build;

A mayor who was often written about in the newspaper by Ernest Hemingway (but Hemingway sure didn't like him);

A mayor who was the city editor of a major Toronto daily newspaper when he ran for mayor;

One who took out a gun and tried to murder a prior mayor (but the gun failed);

The Protestant bigot mayor who was the world's highest official, the Imperial (World) President, of the Loyal Orange Lodge;

The mayor who died on the ice -- playing hockey -- against the City Hall Press Gallery, no less;

The mayor who was living in Montreal when he became mayor ... and didn't even make it back to town for another month;

The mayor who brought Sunday sports and recreation to Toronto (the city swing-sets were padlocked every Sunday, up until then and kids on toboggans could be, and often were, arrested);

The mayor who issued a slur against Catholics on his mayoral City letterhead no less. He lost soon after;

The mayor who was the wealthiest man in Toronto when he became mayor;

Yes, Sam McBride who simply beat up councillors he didn't like;

The mayor who was the father of Canadian pharmacare and medicare (also the only doctor to be the city's mayor);

The mayor who lost after being photographed getting into his own (equivalent value today of $52,000) chauffeur-driven luxury limo, and it was noted he'd only paid $201 in income taxes the year before;

The mayor was defeated for buying a major piece of public art (one that's now worth millions);

The mayor who was an anti-vice, anti-racket, anti-liquor, anti-prostitution, bible thumping moral crusader and social reformer (and Board of Trade President) who coined the term "Toronto the Good", but he was booted off council by a judge;

The mayors who came from the outside -- six of in fact -- with NO prior city council experience;

As mentioned, the mayor who got the job because of a sex scandal, but it wasn't even his scandal: the prior mayor (seeking to returned) had out rented out a house he owned to the city's most notorious hooker. Ooops;

The mayors who were (gasp!) socialists -- just 5 of the 64 -- backed by the left, unions, and NDP (or predecessor the CCF).

Add a Comment

Other Cities: Montreal