Tuesday, February 14, 2012Cloudy 1°C
City

Saturday Brew: Burke Family Tragedy, Racial Profiling, Toronto's Financial Crisis, TTC Vows to Get Better, Ruby Dhalla for Mayor?, Parking Ticket Losses

Posted by Derek Flack / February 6, 2010

TTC TorontoPhoto: "due roundabout now" by jentse, member of the blogTO Flickr pool.

What's happening in the GTA (and sometimes beyond):

Toronto Maple Leafs GM Brian Burke has lost his youngest son to a car accident in Indiana. Whatever one's feelings about the state of our loved and loathed hockey team, a tragedy of this nature transcends the ice. My thoughts and wishes go out to the Burke family at this most difficult time.

Through a freedom of information request, the Toronto Star has found that black people across the GTA are three times more likely to be stopped by the police. I suppose this isn't groundbreaking information -- many have speculated that racial profiling is a police tactic -- but the confirmation is unsettling. Also unsettling is the ridiculous lead photo the paper has run with the article, which depicts two black men, one deemed to be good and the other bad. For a piece that barely hides its moral superiority, this image selection is an embarrassment.

A York University professor argues that the financial mess facing Toronto is downright scary. Citing the $500-million hole in the city's 2010 operating budget, he predicts Toronto's capital debt will skyrocket from $803-million (last year) to a projected $4.69-billion in 2019. Who's to blame? Well, David Miller for one. But, according to Professor Schwartz, Mike Harris and his downloading ways were also critical contributors to our gloomy economy.

The Toronto Sun just can't stop talking about the TTC and its woes. Today's installment, however, throws the Commission a bone by giving spokesperson, Brad Ross, a little paper-space to pledge that things will get better. I know I've been hard on the TTC too, but amidst Ross's promising, the article rejoices in revealing other foolish/lazy behavior on the part of our transit employees. I guess they deserve it, but I'm getting tired of talking about it.

To be fair, the Globe is also capitalizing on the bad buzz, but with an editorial that underscores just how important public transportation is to the life of our city.

Please read this article about the "possibility" that Ruby Dhalla will run for mayor and tell me if it's as bad journalism as I think it is. Yikes.

Mayor Miller is blaming the province for letting parking offenders get away with their offences, and it sounds like he has good reason. More than 100,000 motorists drive away before the officer can hand over the ticket or place it under the windshield wiper each year, but because of an Ontario law, the City doesn't have the power to mail them a ticket. As such, they get off scott-free, costing Toronto almost $5 million in lost revenue.

I don't want to write much about it, but last night's Leaf loss was f-cked!

Discussion

24 Comments

Fig / February 6, 2010 at 11:45 am
user-pic
I echo your thoughts Derek - both on last night's game and sympathy for the Burke family.
Lola / February 6, 2010 at 12:03 pm
user-pic
The Toronto Sun in a joke! Incidentally, so is Ruby Dhalla. But it would be nice to see some women in the mayoral race.
gadfly / February 6, 2010 at 12:13 pm
user-pic
Why do you think no one is stepping forward to become Mayor? Any clown that can balance their chequebook can tell this city is New York, circa 1975 but without the glitter! That's why I've decided to keep on renting and not dip into this real estate bubble: with taxes set to ratchet up, the jig is up.

As to the racial profiling - puhlease! When I was in my early 20s, I got pulled over all the time, stopped on the street, harassed, etc. - and I am white! It's the cop's way, and they were (somewhat) right to wonder what I was doing wandering the streets at 3 and 4 in the morning. If you're young, drive a $2k Honda with $5k worth of rubber and indigo lights glowing underneath - HELLO!
Randy / February 6, 2010 at 12:18 pm
user-pic
The next issue the TTC can address is the constant problem with streetcar and bus drivers, and their buddies standing next to them while try drive. It isn't a social outting, this person is driving a vehicle. More often than not, the dunderhead TTC employee standing next to the driver blocks the way for people getting on the vehicle, often refusing to move. This situation is especially bad on the Queen 501 streetcar.

Unless you're actually there for a purpose, get the f#ck out of the way so people can board the streetcar!
yeahiknow / February 6, 2010 at 12:50 pm
user-pic
Of course the police are gonna racial profile black people. look at the number of black people who are in gangs in this city. look at how many black people are murder victims or commit the crime. it is high. now i am not saying that other races don;t commit these type of crimes in this city, they do. But it see,s everytime i hear or read about a murder/shooting it seems a black person has done it or was killed. yeah i know this sounds racist, but look at the stats, it is surprising.
chephy / February 6, 2010 at 12:52 pm
user-pic
Um, what would be unsettling is lack of what you call racial profiling given that certain ethnical groups are more likely to commit crimes than others. That'd be a waste of taxpayers money to appear politically correct. Are you gonna want the crime rate to go up because the police are afraid to stop someone because he is black? Are you gonna want police to waste resources stopping random whites and asians just to even out numbers? What are they to do if most people involved in "suspicious activity and loitering" do happen to be black? What if of all people involved in such "suspicious activity", blacks end up more likely to actually be doing something illicit? Of course, one can question the whole system - do the police have the right to interfere with lives of citizens who are not committing a criminal act? If we feel they should not have this right, then the criticism should be directed at the fact that it's happening at all. But if we do think that the system is okay in principle, then the police needs to do what's efficient, not what's PC.

I also bet that more males get stopped than females. And that younger people are more likely to be stopped than older folks. Is this kind of sex and age profiling unacceptable? Or is it wise, given that young men are far more likely to commit crimes than elderly ladies?
dreamy replying to a comment from chephy / February 6, 2010 at 01:26 pm
user-pic
Holy S*@T. Your argument is ridiculous! To your point then. The majority pedophiles, and organized crime members, and white collar criminals are white, at least based on those incidents reported in the newspaper. So then shouldn't police be stopping more white people? If you start increasing the random checks of any group of course you are going to find more criminals. The fact is that, per-capita, black people are not anymore likely to commit a crime than anyone else.
So YES! Your argument is racist…oh, and dumb.
jack / February 6, 2010 at 02:03 pm
user-pic
asians are also more likely to get asked to check their monthly TTC pass too... esp at Finch subway station
cocoa / February 6, 2010 at 02:09 pm
user-pic
Hopefully the Shwartz study opens a few eyes about the state of the city's finances. Rossi was pilloried for saying he would sell Hydro, but it should be clear by now that we'll have to make dramatic concessions to pay down our debt in the interest of our long-term financial health.

I hope the other mayoral candidates start having these tough conversations with the electorate. Unless Giambrone dedicates a significant portion of his platform to how he would right our financial situation he is not worth a second look. Miller was wonderful but unaffordable, we need to come to terms with that.
everyone's racist / February 6, 2010 at 02:16 pm
user-pic
Hmm. Let's waste time stopping people based on skin colour so we don't appear racist to the Toronto Star! Facts are, people are stopped more often in high crime areas. These are also areas that are predominantly black. Thus more blacks are stopped and questioned on average in the city. It ain't rocket science. Seems some people prefer political correctness to policing.
mike replying to a comment from dreamy / February 6, 2010 at 02:22 pm
user-pic
uh, that "fact" doesn't bear out with the relative population of blacks in prison, compared to their overall population.

blacks are overrepresented in jail, in the legal system - why that's the case is the topic for some history course - but that's the fact, I don't know where you get your "fact" about all populations being just as likely to commit crimes. On the face of it that seems ridiculous.

So there's more crime among the poor, esp. poor black, so they get hassled more - what do you expect. The problem isn't the cops, the problem is the poverty, and the messed up culture that goes along with it.
saltspring replying to a comment from Randy / February 6, 2010 at 03:27 pm
user-pic
"dunderhead"...wow, the last time I heard that word, it was my mother saying it, and she's 86!! Thx for the memories, Randy ;-)
saltspring replying to a comment from everyone's racist / February 6, 2010 at 03:33 pm
user-pic
This is the most sensible post on this topic so far.

To stir the pot, Muslims should be selectively profiled as potential terrorists, as we don't see many non-Muslims wearing explosive belts and looking forward to virgins in heaven (I wonder what those female suicide bombers look forward to?). Sure, we get the occasional McVeigh and Unabomber, but that's random psychosis, not organized jihad.
Jim replying to a comment from saltspring / February 6, 2010 at 05:40 pm
user-pic
Muslims being profiled. I agree with you, however as it is difficult to tell who is Muslim just by looking at them, it would be safer to just say "all brown people". That way you don't miss anyone because they left their prayer matt at home. And instead of spending all that money on security personel, why don't we just say "no brown people allowed to fly" How does that sound? Oh and if you go to Cuba on holidays and on your way back you have a tan... well forget about getting on that plane. We're not taking the risk.
Christopher replying to a comment from dreamy / February 6, 2010 at 08:15 pm
user-pic
I agree with @yeahiknow.
Regardless of whether the police are profiling or not, just about every time you hear about some one getting shot in this city, or knifed, lo and behold, they're black, and the person police now have in custody, are .... surprise surprise!! Black, or maybe mulatto.
Don't blame the police for why they're doing what they're doing. Ask Jim Junkin! He knows why.

saltspring / February 6, 2010 at 09:17 pm
user-pic
Hmmm...seems blogTO likes to censor posts that are remotely offensive to militant populations. That's a shame. Jim, I like your humour.
Marc replying to a comment from Christopher / February 6, 2010 at 11:34 pm
user-pic
Completely agree and complete common sense and obviousness, Christopher King. The answer is always clear, and has been, unfortunately.
chephy replying to a comment from dreamy / February 7, 2010 at 12:02 am
user-pic
Riiiight... the best way to catch white-collar criminals and organized crime members is to stop them on the street and ask them a few questions, eh? And of course what can tip you to the fact that they are in an organized crime ring is their loitering and suspicious behaviour in public places, usually shady high-crime areas! Gee, I'm glad the police weren't smart enough to think of that one!

You know, I don't think that's exactly a very smart way of going after that sort of evildoers. The police seems to share my viewpoint, it would seem.
chephy replying to a comment from dreamy / February 7, 2010 at 12:13 am
user-pic
"The fact is that, per-capita, black people are not anymore likely to commit a crime than anyone else."

That's why nearly every time someone is murdered in this city, the murderer (and the victim) tends to be... no, wait, don't tell, me, let me guess... uh, I donno... black?... Wow. Astounding.

And that's why Toronto banned collecting race-based crime statistics. Because a report by Julian Fantino in 1989 showed that all races were equally likely to commit crimes, so why bother... Oops, no, scratch that, I think I got that last one a little mixed up.
chephy replying to a comment from everyone's racist / February 7, 2010 at 12:23 am
user-pic
That's not the whole story. Had you read the article carefully, you would have noticed that areas like North Toronto (low-crime, very few blacks) especially stand out in this regard; there the profiling may be attributed to the "don't fit in" factor.

However, no one is questioning whether it is because the police are targeting race, or because they are targeting certain activities, and blacks just happen to be engaged in those activities more often than representatives of other races. How on earth can you blame the police if the latter is the case? What next - you demand that the police go out and find more white murderers? Preferably 80-year-old grannies? To even out the numbers, you know. 'Cause there can be no way they are less likely to commit violent crimes than 20-year-old black males. That would be racist, sexist and ageist to even dare to suggest such a thing!

To think of all the evil grannies who've gotten away with murder because of the police discriminatory attitudes to suspects! Tsk, tsk, tsk!
asau / February 7, 2010 at 12:24 pm
user-pic
if police starting profiling other races I bet crimes by the would increase . all races commit crimes but police don't investigate all races equally . lets be real white pole commit the most crimes in Canada that why all jails in this country are full of them.
Nick / February 7, 2010 at 02:05 pm
user-pic
Dhalla didn't just deny the Nannygate incident, she was actually 100 per cent cleared by an investigating committee. Obviously the Toronto Sun wasn't able to figure that out. But what's new?
Freeman / February 24, 2010 at 10:55 pm
user-pic
Can anyone here honestly say they dont know a white drug dealer?
what is every fucking thing replying to a comment from Freeman / February 6, 2011 at 09:04 pm
user-pic
i dont know a white drug dealer!

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal