Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 21°C
City

Morning Brew: Manslaughter Acquittals in Jane Creba Case, Street-racing Law Deemed Unconstitutional (again!), Deer Wandering in Downtown Core, TTC Ushers Help Relieve Commuter Congestion, Funky Bikes for City Staff

Posted by Jerrold Litwinenko / November 24, 2009

front porchPhoto: untitled by sa-ra-ha, member of the blogTO Flickr pool.

What's happening in the GTA (and sometimes beyond):

Four of the remaining seven who stood accused of manslaughter in the 2005 Boxing Day shootout slaying of Jane Creba near Yonge-Dundas Square have been acquitted. The crown wouldn't likely have been able to convict them, given that these four didn't fire any weapons. Are the many years they've already spent in jail punishment enough for being associates with those that did fire guns?

Once again, an Ontario judge (this time in Newmarket) has deemed the provincial street-racing law unconstitutional. Without the ability of the accused to present a defence, the potential six-month prison sentence the law carries seems very wrong. The Attorney General believes the law is sound, but it's looking more and more like adjustments to or abolishment of the law are not far away.

If you're heading downtown today, be aware that a brave and bewildered deer somehow ended up strolling into the urban concrete-laden core. Animal control is on the case and will likely round the beast up in short order.

Why didn't the TTC hop on board (pun intended) when the PRESTO card was being offered as an option back in 2006? GO Transit, and regional systems in Oakville, Mississauga, York Region, Durham Region, Brampton, Hamilton, Burlington and Ottawa are all rolling out the smartcard as automated fare payment, but the country's largest system balked on it, citing costs. Now the TTC is showing interest, and is years behind the rest.

In an effort to curb congestion at the Yonge and Bloor subway stations during rush hour, the TTC is testing a new strategy that involves ushering the crowds and dispersing them more evenly across the platforms. It's too bad people can't figure this out themselves, but hopefully after a few weeks of coaxing the behavior becomes habit and the transit staff involved can return to more important roles. Congestion during rush hour sucks, but it could be MUCH worse.

Funky bikes for city staff, instead of motor vehicles? Seems like a great idea. Too bad a safety course is required, and that we live in a city that prevents this kind of program from being popular for more than just a few months out of the year.

And Famous BBQ on Queen West has rats lounging around within view of passersby with cameras, and the guy who runs the nearby Payless Shoes is concerned that other businesses nearby are at risk. Imagine trying on a shoe with a rodent camping in the dark toe area? Eek!

Discussion

23 Comments

Rob / November 24, 2009 at 09:37 am
user-pic
We all know why the TTC passed on the PRESTO card, and it WAS costs related - costs that they would have to divert from unionized ticket takers, and we all know that wouldn't fly
meh replying to a comment from Rob / November 24, 2009 at 09:39 am
user-pic
Someone doesn't know the difference between captial and operating costs.
why? / November 24, 2009 at 09:48 am
user-pic
Has anyone noticed that on all the subways, the TTC maps have been taken down? Just an observation.
Peter K / November 24, 2009 at 09:54 am
user-pic
I wonder how much ushers are getting paid.
TokyoTuds / November 24, 2009 at 09:55 am
user-pic
This is my #1 favourite Japan train videos (it is actually a commuter train like GO, not the subway). In fact, it might be my old line in Tokyo called the Seibu Line. After all these years, I still laugh out loud at that video. I love how the one staff seems to be supervising, then suddenly jumps in to help his mates push commuter limbs in.
Derek / November 24, 2009 at 09:55 am
user-pic
Comments have been removed from this thread due to their expression of racist attitudes. The replies to these comments have also been removed for the sake of context/clarity, but were in no way racist themselves. Asoc. Ed.
Elle Driver / November 24, 2009 at 10:03 am
user-pic
It should also be noted that Toronto-based singer Jacksoul died over the weekend. After suffering horrific injuries from a scooter accident a few years ago, his rehabilitation appeared to be on the upswing, but succumbed to lung cancer on Saturday. Very sad and unexpected.
Ryan L. replying to a comment from meh / November 24, 2009 at 10:18 am
user-pic
I think what he might be saying is that a smart card system would reduce the need for collectors at stations. Collectors who would very much not appreciate losing their job. Collectors who are part of a very powerful union.
Elizabeth / November 24, 2009 at 10:24 am
user-pic
I cannot believe that Tokyo video. Insanity!
Presto / November 24, 2009 at 10:25 am
user-pic
The point is the TTC is only now considering a Presto card system.

GO Transit, Oakville, Mississauga, York Region, Durham Region Brampton, Hamilton, Burlington, Ottawa made this decision three years ago, yet the largest system in Canada is only now considering the measure, which tells you why the TTC is such a mess.

G Smith replying to a comment from Presto / November 24, 2009 at 11:03 am
user-pic
Language is a funny thing, especially when it is casually used to suggest that an organization that is well aware of its options and spends a great deal of time examining them is blissfully ignorant.

Obviously the TTC "considered" Presto before. It "considered" it, and decided it didn't have the money. It is not "only now considering" Presto -- how else could it have said no?

Disagree with their past decision, fine, but nonsense is unhelpful.
Rob replying to a comment from Ryan L. / November 24, 2009 at 11:07 am
user-pic
Thank you. I thought it was obvious, but I guess you have to spell things out explicitly for some people.

This is similar to the Scarborough RT which has the ability to operate automatically via computer control but still has a "driver" as "The transit workers' union has firmly opposed driverless trains.[5]". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scarborough_RT_%28TTC%29#Trains
G Smith replying to a comment from Ryan L. / November 24, 2009 at 11:10 am
user-pic
No doubt the TTC would find other work for those collectors, if any (most stations would still require some attendants), displaced by Presto. As you pointed out, union protection would likely mean they'd be shuffled elsewhere rather than laid off.

As with meh's point above re: capital/operating budgets, armchair accountants and armchair labour relations advisors need not apply.
Nonsense replying to a comment from G Smith / November 24, 2009 at 11:30 am
user-pic
So after saying they need to raise fares because they're losing money, they somehow have the money to consider it now?

Didn't they also say a Presto card system (indeed any card system) would be too expensive and too difficult to implement?
G Smith replying to a comment from Nonsense / November 24, 2009 at 11:42 am
user-pic
Fares needed to rise to cover an <em>operating</em> deficit, yes. Do you really doubt this? Really? Or is this still more budget ignorance/dyslexia?

Presto was rejected in the past based on the <em>capital</em> cost to equip thousands of payment points (ballparked in the hundreds of millions of dollars as I recall offhand). This is money that the TTC does not have. Do you doubt this? I do not. There is no secret pot of gold hidden at Davisville.

Therefore, one assumes any serious consideration of Presto now is a fishing expedition (backed up by this week's physical fare media chaos at Bloor-Yonge and elsewhere) for an investment from Queen's Park that was not forthcoming last time 'round.

Incongruity begs for explanation, not exasperation.
truth replying to a comment from G Smith / November 24, 2009 at 11:55 am
user-pic
Presto and other cards have capital costs but would produce mammoth operating savings by allowing the elimination of staff positions. Normal companies and people do these kinds of things, and even private sector unions have accepted reality in this, after fighting productivity enhancements for centuries (the actual, original Luddites) up to the early 80s protests against computers in the workplace.

FIRE THEM ALL.
Mark Dowling / November 24, 2009 at 12:09 pm
user-pic
It is simply unbelievable that this project required AT LEAST 31 TTC staff and special constables as of 8.15 this morning (yes, I counted having been amazed by the number the previous morning) - several of whom just seemed to be milling about doing nothing in particular, others being biological signpost holders.
G Smith / November 24, 2009 at 12:11 pm
user-pic
Where in reality -- as opposed to anti-union paranoiacs in these comment threads -- has anyone credibly suggested that the union is <em>actually</em> standing in the the way of Presto implementation?

And no doubt, spending on the capital side <em>can</em> (but won't necessarily, the devil being in the details) bring operating savings. I wouldn't suggest otherwise -- indeed, I've responded here to others' (feigned?) surprise at the TTC's simultaneous need to a fare increase (due to no $) and off-and-on interest in Presto (which costs $).

It's a shame, it seemed like you might be a pragmatic thinker up for a reasonable discussion of the options that are actually on the table... until the "FIRE THEM ALL" drivel, that is.
G Smith replying to a comment from Mark Dowling / November 24, 2009 at 12:11 pm
user-pic
How long would an non-biological signpost have remained upright, I wonder? Honest question... I transfer at St. George.
NotProvenGuilty / November 24, 2009 at 12:14 pm
user-pic
Re: Creba: Is being in jail for almost 4 years and being acquitted "fair"? One of the 4 was able to make bail (and the others were either denied bail or couldn't afford it... it doesn't say)... is the one who was out on bail unpunished enough for you, given that he apparently didn't commit a crime that could be prosecuted? I'm uncomfortable with your question and (perhaps inadvertent) use of language.
Joel M / November 24, 2009 at 02:05 pm
user-pic
I'm glad that street racing law is going to get reversed. I hate people who drive too fast but this law allows too much room for corruption. You cannot have police officers being judges and juries. Our entire legal system is based on being innocent until proven guilty, but with this law your car is gone and your licence is revoked before you have your day in court.

Many officers also target very interesting areas, such as the exit ramp on Park Lawn Ave, where the limit suddenly drops from 100 to 50, forcing people to slam on their brakes to avoid their cars being taken away. It seems they are interested in picking off people who don't slow down just enough, even though there are stop lights at the end of the ramp.

Not long ago there was a story of a Peel Region police officer caught charging people with this law when they weren't speeding. He was being paid off by a tow truck driver for the impound fees from this law. Corruption happens, and this law is a perfect recipe for it because there is no oversight, or defense allowed.

Our legal system isn't by any means perfect but when you start handing out punishments before convictions, it's quite a slippery slope.
jack / November 24, 2009 at 03:04 pm
user-pic
i think the problem with presto is that it will make subway ride so much easier, that leads to more riders.. and more riders will cost ttc to lose money.. so it is again a no go.. ttc doesnt want any more riders.. they want people who pay but don't ride.. that's the only way they can be profitable..
chephy / November 25, 2009 at 12:19 am
user-pic
Oh. Now you have to follow the orders of a TTC guy who will tell you where you're going to be on the platform. Niiiice.....

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal