Saturday, February 11, 2012Partly Cloudy -10°C
City

Toronto City Union Strike is Over?

Posted by Jerrold Litwinenko / July 27, 2009

toronto garbage strikeThe Toronto city union strike is very close to being over.

After 36 days off the job (and following a night of midnight oil burning, marathon talks) Mark Ferguson, the head of union representing outside workers under CUPE Local 416, took to the mic at 8:30am and announced that a tentative deal has been reached but is conditional on Local 416 member ratification.

He encouraged the city to get the same from inside workers of CUPE Local 79, who have yet to reach a deal with the city. Hopefully member ratification happens quickly for both unions and all workers return to the job soon.

A late night message from Ann Dembinski, the president of Local 79 to their members, was posted to their web page and suggests that things are pointing towards an agreement: "I want to let all Local 79 members know that we believe we are close to a negotiated settlement."

It's clearly a bittersweet moment for both sides. Details of the tentative agreement are not yet being released but will become known in the fullness of time. Ferguson is reportedly saying that no concessions were made on the union's part. Mayor Miller is remaining hum. Hopefully everyone is happy with a settlement that meets the demands of both sides, somewhere in the middle.

I'm sure we're all especially looking forward to the return of garbage collection, the cleanup of our city's parks (many of which have acted as temporary garbage dumps), the return of city-run daycare and event services.

Photo by swilton.

Discussion

23 Comments

Dan / July 27, 2009 at 08:44 am
user-pic
Not so fast... Local 79 hasn't reached their deal yet, and 416 won't vote/ratify until 79 reaches their deal.
citypainter / July 27, 2009 at 08:47 am
user-pic
Well, not quite. Only one of the two unions (416) has reached a tentative "framework" for a deal. The other union (79) has yet to reach a deal, nothing has been ratified, and in the meantime the pickets stay up. It's all very promising but a "Strike is Over" headline is a bit premature... don't jinx us!
picard102 / July 27, 2009 at 09:23 am
user-pic
I swear, if the damn city caved to their silly demands.
Sean / July 27, 2009 at 09:25 am
user-pic
A deal, perhaps. The union members must vote on that. If they don't like it, the pickets will stay on indefinitely.

In the meantime, miller will try to grab the headlines on this. A staunch NDP, he practically endorsed the strike.

TO ALL MEDIA: During the next municipal election campaign, make sure you give attention to those that have no current or past political affiliations and must be 100% independent. Let's hope you focus on all those that never get the press they deserve for the seat as mayor of Toronto. That includes town hall meetings etc. When you ignore them, we the voters ignore you.
Chris / July 27, 2009 at 09:26 am
user-pic
I honetsly think it's time the union accepted an offer and allowed workers to get back to work. At this point, the longer the strike goes on, the less favorably I look on the union. Information has been sketchy at best and the union's stance on banked sick days is almost laughable since there are very few professions that get them.

I definitely don't know all the information - but not for lack of trying. It's time to end the strike, before these unions alienate everyone.
Ryan L. / July 27, 2009 at 09:39 am
user-pic
So how does the union go about giving a 'deadline'?

Do they just refuse to come back to work ever unless the city meets their demands?

To me that just sounds like the union trying to bluff the city into caving in a last ditch effort. Sadly, it seems to have worked.
eric / July 27, 2009 at 09:58 am
user-pic
Even if the union doesn't get what they want money wise, the amount of overtime they will charge to the city to clean up the results of their strike will likely make up the difference. Hate them though you may you have to respect how cleverly they've played us all.
jeff / July 27, 2009 at 09:59 am
user-pic
Hold on... Ferguson stated a deal was only possible once the city removed all the demands for concessions from the deal!

If so, and I expect it is, this was all for not and the Mayor et al have screwed this BIG.

I resent being held hostage by these people and would rather see the unions crushed in favor of contracting out and gaining competition, greater efficiencies and better service.
Suzie / July 27, 2009 at 10:21 am
user-pic
Somehow the union ended up with the upperhand.

Don't forget to buy the tags/stickers to go onto all of your garbage bags if you want them picked up.
Sean Galbraith replying to a comment from eric / July 27, 2009 at 10:29 am
user-pic
My guess is that the City has a TON of private garbage companies on-call for the minute the contract is ratified to swoop in and start the cleanup (to minimize the overtime).
eric replying to a comment from Sean Galbraith / July 27, 2009 at 10:40 am
user-pic
That is a great deal of faith to have in a city council that has gotten us to this point Sean. While you, myself and most people of common sense would see the logic in using private companies the fact is it simply isn't going to happen, I can all but guarantee it. The unionized workers will clean it up to their typical sub-par standards, will take their time doing so and will charge the city (us) with every cent of overtime they can.
Jule / July 27, 2009 at 10:46 am
user-pic
I thought originally it was said that there would be no overtime for the clean up. AFTER the last strike I thought the city was smart enough to not let this happen again.
Mark Dowling replying to a comment from Sean Galbraith / July 27, 2009 at 11:53 am
user-pic
Sean there's no way the City can clear the garbage with private haulers - how else will the workers earn enough overtime to make back what they lost in the strike, in the spirit of "fairness" and all...
kyliep / July 27, 2009 at 12:18 pm
user-pic
great. when does the next election campaign start? any candidate for mayor or councillor running with a plan to privatize these services gets my vote.
John / July 27, 2009 at 01:44 pm
user-pic
I am truely grateful I don't live in Toronto and when crap like this keeps happening I will never consider the thought.
I agree with most people here that state that trash collection should be privatized and/or contracted out, At least this way should they go on strike, you can simply class it as a breach of contract and hire another company to take over.

Unions use to stand for something, not anymore, from my experience with them, they only protected the slackers, those who didn't want to work "too hard" even when the job was easy. And when I hear these people asking for things that no other company in their right mind would accept, disgusts me.
It's time for these people to put things into perspective. Mr. Miller needs to grow a pair, and step up.... Tax payers pay for this service! If it was any other business they would be asking for their money back and they would get it..but here all I see are a bunch of terrorist demands where people either have to give them what they want or suffer the fallout.
Personally I always thought If you don't like you f-ing job get a new one!

Additionally, and I hate to say it but, if I recall correctly T.O. had a SARS outbreak shortly after the last one, so It wouldn't suprise me if T.O. has another outbreak this year.
Jamie / July 27, 2009 at 02:06 pm
user-pic
Don't forget to tag your garbage bags if you EXPECT them to get picked up!!!

If it doesn't fit in your bin it MUST be tagged.
Jamie / July 27, 2009 at 02:15 pm
user-pic
What should I do with extra bags of garbage?
Extra garbage bags can be left beside your Garbage Bin if you attach a City-issued yellow garbage bag tag to each bag. Five free yellow garbage bag tags were mailed directly to property owners in November 2008. These tags will expire on December 31, 2009.

Additional yellow garbage bag tags are available in packages of five for $15.50 ($3.10 each) at City of Toronto Canadian Tire stores and at Commissioners St. Drop-off Depot. Residents may also bring their garbage to a transfer station and pay a fee for disposal.

http://www.toronto.ca/target70/qa.htm#a49
Vic De Zen / July 27, 2009 at 02:22 pm
user-pic
As one of my friends said "It isn't over until the garbage is off the ground."
Luciano Galasso / July 27, 2009 at 02:32 pm
user-pic
Let's just hope this is over with soon. I'm sick of looking at the garbage on the streets, not to mention the smell. At least the via strike ended quickly.
-- Luciano Galasso
Jeromy / July 27, 2009 at 03:25 pm
user-pic
Union workers should get paid overtime if working overtime, its not a bonus or a gift, its overtime.
This was a legal strike, nobody broke the law. When they comeback to work should they be asked to work extra hours they should be paid overtime.
eric replying to a comment from Jeromy / July 27, 2009 at 03:41 pm
user-pic
You have an interesting definition of the term legal Jeromy. Legal would mean they have no right to block transfer stations or hold cars. Tell me where it is written in any law book that says if they are on strike they have the right to detain me. Of course the union cops and the union loving politicians turned a blind eye to this and left defenseless.

Had they let citizens simply deal with their garbage and dispose of it without illegal detaining people in their cars, I honestly believe that we wouldn't have seen so much illegal dumping, and we wouldn't be facing such a terrible aftermath.

aaron replying to a comment from eric / July 27, 2009 at 05:10 pm
user-pic
I believe the courts have determined that delaying people's access actually IS legal (informational picketing). Preventing people's access completely is what is illegal, and that's when injunctions have been sought. Just because it's an inconvenience and annoying doesn't mean it's illegal.
Chris / August 3, 2009 at 04:46 pm
user-pic
Although an unintentional slowdown may occur as a result of a legal information picket, an intentional slowdown is not an information picket just because you like that term. A panhandler can not make you wait for 5 minutes while they inform you about why you should give them money. In fact, the cops give panhandlers tickets for asking the same person for money more than once in the same interaction. Call it what you want, but I bet you'd be angry if I "information picketed" your office.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal