Saturday, May 26, 2012Mostly Cloudy 18°C
City

UofT Faces Its Own Labour Dispute

Posted by Brady Yauch / January 20, 2009

University of TorontoWhile the strike up at York University continues to grab all the headlines, there's another dispute taking place at the University of Toronto. Before Christmas break, members from CUPE 3902, representing TAs and Course Instructors, voted in favour of a strike mandate--authorizing the union's officials to call for a strike should talks with the University break down. Conciliation talks between officials from U of T and union leaders began this week and are expected to last until the end of the month.

What They Want

The union is asking the university to cover University Health Insurance Plan (UHIP). premiums for international students. UHIP is a private for-profit healthcare plan that currently charges about $3000 per year to cover international students and their families. The union is also looking for better childcare assistance and improved maternity/parental leave provisions to members with children. It's asking for smaller tutorial and lab sizes, while ensuring experienced TAs aren't forced out of the classroom. And the union wants to defend tuition assistance for unfunded students, which the university is trying to eliminate.

A spokesperson from the CUPE 3902 says that after months of deadlock, U of T is showing movement on maternity/parental leave, tutorial and lab sizes and a number of smaller issues. She also said that although U of T and the union have yet to come to any agreement, talk of a strike is premature, as the two sides have the next couple of weeks to work through their disagreements.

Plus, the relationship between U of T and the union is far more functional than the situation up at York--as both sides are closer on a number of key issues and the dynamics between the parties is far more functional.

The labour disagreement at U of T comes at an interesting time for university officials. In the wake of the ongoing strike at York, an increasing number of students are looking to looking to get their education elsewhere. A recent report from the province's application centre says the number of students selecting York at their first choice has fallen by 15 percent this year. York has fallen to fourth place in the number of first-year applications in Ontario--down from the second place it traditionally claims.

Officials from universities across the province and the country are likely to take note. If tensions between faculty and the university are so distraught that strikes become a common occurrence, students might just ply their trade elsewhere. But on the other hand, the unions need to ensure they don't exploit the opportunity and ask for outrageous demands. Because, in the end, a strike hurts the students the most.

Photo: Warm Bath by ethervizion

Discussion

18 Comments

RF / January 20, 2009 at 03:23 pm
user-pic
It's worth noting that the "vote in favour of a strike mandate" (which is distinct from a vote for a strike) only garnered 60% support. Very weak.
Khuffie / January 20, 2009 at 04:19 pm
user-pic
Using the $3000 dollar figure is kind of misleading, don't you think? For a single international student, health care coverage is $700. As an international student, I really had no problem paying that and coming to Canada to study was far cheaper than going to the states or the UK, AND I got health coverage. If they university is going to cover those premiums, then you can be sure that fees for international students are going to increase by said amount of premiums, so I don't see how that part would really benefit anyone.
handfed / January 20, 2009 at 05:08 pm
user-pic
CUPE3092 is trying to pull the big one on all our heads, people. This thing is a sham! The so-called "vote" for a strike mandate was illegitimate and dominated by greedy self-indulgent sociopaths. There are *no* outstanding issues between the Union and the University with much significance. The CUPE3092 leadership sees how well the York Unionists have beefed up their resumes, and asked: Hey, we should do that!
Reality Check / January 20, 2009 at 07:41 pm
user-pic
It is beyond time to disestablish government unions. There are no legitimate reasons for any government workers to form a union - all the contracts should be voided and closed shops opened up.

Seriously grad students going on strike? They get huge amounts of funding and yet want to strike. Strip them of their right to unionize and then tear up their contracts. Let's get some serious negotiations done, maybe a roll back of 50% or more on costs. Grad school needs to be more expensive so that people focus on actually useful areas of study, not MSW or MA.
krystyn / January 20, 2009 at 08:07 pm
user-pic
Good lord this better be resolved or I won't be able to graduate and go to grad school in September as planned.
Eglinton replying to a comment from Reality Check / January 20, 2009 at 08:30 pm
user-pic
oh no you di'nt
Paul / January 20, 2009 at 09:52 pm
user-pic
In related news, the you-know-what's led by the anti-semite voted 63% against accepting YorkU's latest offer.

Something needs to be done to curb abuse of union power.
wes / January 20, 2009 at 10:36 pm
user-pic
$3000 for UHIP is inaccurate.
timothy / January 20, 2009 at 10:40 pm
user-pic
@Reality Check - Why so elitist? I hated part of university because of people like you, who walk around campus thinking that any non-science student is a worthless piece of trash.
Paul / January 20, 2009 at 10:41 pm
user-pic
Oh and continuing with the YorkU news, I heard that a CUPE member punched a outspoken anti-strike prof in the stomach.

Since Obama is closing down Gitmo, we don't we fill it up with these guys? Interrogators can practice waterboarding, and Canada can become a greater place to live in.
Karen / January 21, 2009 at 10:56 am
user-pic
Actually Wes, UHIP does cost over $3000 to insure a student and their family:

http://www.uhip.ca/content/objects/2008-09_Premium_Rates-ENG.pdf
handfed / January 21, 2009 at 01:46 pm
user-pic
Karen: WRONG! I am an international grad student and unwilling member of CUPE3092, I just checked my financial account on ROSI and my UHIP fees are $756 per YEAR. Thanks for your uninformed opinion.
Heather replying to a comment from handfed / January 21, 2009 at 02:30 pm
user-pic
Karen's not wrong - and she's not uninformed, it isn't really an opinion when you're producing stats from UHIP. $756 is the minimum for a year it will cost one person. If there are 2 people (say a married grad student) it would be $2,052, throw in a kid and you're looking at $3,348.

I'm denying to know your major Handfed!
Heather / January 21, 2009 at 02:48 pm
user-pic
Ha - I'm also under-caffinated. Snarky comment fail. :(
TA / January 21, 2009 at 07:02 pm
user-pic
Hey Handfed, how about attempting to learn about the issues before spewing your lame insults and lazy arguments.

The union's proposals are fair and reasonable. I haven't seen a single substantive critique of them on this blog, just a lot of reactionary union bashing and cowardly name calling.

If you hate unions, that's fine. If you are a member of 3902, you'll benefit from bargaining whether you've contributed to the union or not and that's fine too. Just get your facts straight!
handfed / January 22, 2009 at 12:56 pm
user-pic
oh hey YAAAy someone actually replied to my comment, after all this time of lurking on blogto! Now I feel like I've contributed something... to humanity...
Toronto Lofts / January 23, 2009 at 04:05 am
user-pic
The union's proposals are fair and reasonable. I haven't seen a single substantive critique of them on this blog,
rolex replica / May 11, 2009 at 03:37 am
user-pic
A spokesperson from the CUPE 3902 says that after months of deadlock, U of T is showing movement on maternity/parental leave, tutorial and lab sizes and a number of smaller issues.

Add a Comment

Other Cities: VancouverMontreal