Toronto's Forgotten Landmarks: Metropolitan United Church Parsonage

Filed in City
November 5, 2008

Metropolitan United Church ParsonageOn the south-west corner of Church and Shuter, nestled between two of Toronto's oldest, largest, and most spectacular churches is the beautiful Metropolitan United Church Parsonage.

I use the term 'is' here very liberally, for as you read this, the more modern portion of the building (1929 as opposed to the original 1906 western section) is being torn apart.

During my first visit a few Sundays ago, I was able to see the structure in its entirety, but upon visiting it again some 2 days later, I witnessed a large Lions tractor making a convertible of the eastern sections.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
Now, I realize that that Lions and Christians do not have the most amicable history (almost as ironic as when I witness Priestly demolition co. tearing down a church), but what I find particularly irksome in this situation is twofold. Firstly, I had spoken to a foreman some weeks before, who informed me that they would be saving and transplanting the stones, even from the 'newer' section (consisting mainly of a recreation centre and a daycare), moving them adjacent to Bond street itself.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
Secondly, what this older part of downtown Toronto is going to have instead of a gorgeous early 20th century neo-gothic structure is a massive underground car-park topped off with a shiny new glass-n-plastic condominium.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
I have worked in this neighbourhood for almost a decade, and the vertical view of the beautiful twin steeples gazing south has always brought a bit of warmth to the area, reminding us of our city's past as bank towers stretch southward not a few blocks to the west.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
Over the past half-decade, those who have lived and worked in this area have born witness to the sweeping changes that have taken place in this neighbourhood; from the loss of Toronto's last example of Georgian style homes to 'demolition by neglect' (in this case, the building had to literally start falling over before the city/owner took action), to the police-raids which ended the crime-haven pawn shop mis-dealings along Church St.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
This unquestioned replacement of our solid cornerstones leaves me uneasy. I could go on at length about unbridled condo development, how the city has sold out every last inch of waterfront and whatnot, but sadly, these so called developments speak to a larger problem of cultural amnesia.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
These are our neighbourhoods, and community is built on story and place. From an architectural point of view, I could hail signs of the times - show how Goya's doubt lead to a Corbusian, utilitarian reign, but if anything, this brings us farther away from the sidewalks we traverse.

Metropolitan United Church Parsonage
We thrive on pattern and recognizability, and create our own stories from the necessary, given, 'built' environment in which we live. For me, beyond the annoyance of traffic derailment as the new structure goes up in the place of the old parsonage, the streets will become less and less recognizable, this place where I spend my days. And after all, how we spend our days is how we spend our lives.

(Below are a few more snaps from the Parsonage - I will be uploading more as the week progresses, when I get my film-shots back from the lab.)

Eric on November 5, 2008 at 10:39 AM

It is a bit unfortunate to see these old buildings go, but it's not like they're tearing down the actual church. The parsonage doesn't add much to the already fairly dead corner of Church and Shuter. The Starbucks adds something I guess.

boywithnoname on November 5, 2008 at 12:00 PM

Oh my goodness. I went to school at St. Michael's Choir School nearby and we used to use the Metropolitain United building for our gym classes. Seeing that stage and basketball net in such condition kind of saddens me.

It's going to be odd to not see that building there anymore on the corner of Shuter and Church.

Heather on November 5, 2008 at 3:44 PM

What a waste.

Thanks for sharing the photos!

OrGaN_DoNoR on November 5, 2008 at 11:16 PM

What a trip. I, too, am a Choir School grad; blows my mind to see my old gymnasium like that. So much time spent there... volleyball, cosmo hockey, dodgeball... wow.
I truly feel old.

boywithnoname on November 6, 2008 at 11:52 AM

I know what you mean OrGaN_DoNoR. I too feel old when reminiscing about the time spent in the "Metro Gym" playing volleyball, basketball, etc.

It's amazing to see how much the landscape in that area has changed since I graduated back in 1999.

It's a shame to see the Metro Gym go.

Annie on November 7, 2008 at 1:52 PM

I'm glad that we got to explore this before they tore most of it down!

Wonderful story and photos, as always.

A.

Jonathan Castellino on November 7, 2008 at 2:30 PM

Thanks, guys!

I'm glad some of you who used to use the facility got to see it's last days-

Jonathan.

iamthegucc on November 9, 2008 at 8:30 PM

Totally wild. I too attended the Choir School. I also captained many basketball teams from the school that used this facility to train and compete. Very bittersweet memories. Thanks for the photos....

Iremember on November 10, 2008 at 9:16 AM

HOLY @$#$!!!

I went to the Choir School and have 2 brothers that went before me! We ALL played in that gym.. We had gym class, track practise after school, SOCCER BASEBALL and obviously basketball!!

My fondest memories were just chillin' on the stage behind the net and watchin my brothers play (and sneaking into the room with all the gym supplies!!).. haha

Mr. Lapointe had NO IDEA!!! hahha... great memories thank you SO MUCH for the photos

Peter on March 9, 2009 at 9:41 PM

I was shocked to see the building demolished yesterday. My daycare days was spent there in the early 1960's. A Toronto Star photographer took a photo of me, Shirley and another boy (I believe his name was Neil) and featured us in the newspaper. My parents have the newspaper clip in a photo album.

b on March 31, 2009 at 3:52 PM

sad to see it go. it has been a long time since i stepped in there as a choir school student. the photos brought back a flood of memories. i remember a certain school mate spiking a volleyball so high it smashed one of the roof lights, lol.

i also remember seeing it in a bank commercial, scotiabank i believe ...

thanks for the photos, even tho they are photoshopped ...

Jonathan on March 31, 2009 at 4:44 PM

Brent - ya,it was sad to see it go; they kept a portion of it, at least (to be fused w/ the new development). Viewing photo-editing (I use LR + and Hp program, btw, not PS) as a 'negative' is like complaining when dark-room developers manipulate shots in their space (which I do as well) - besides, I've seen your stuff - you edit as well ; P

Jonathan@blogTO

b on March 31, 2009 at 5:01 PM , replying to a comment from Jonathan

sorry, jono, didn't mean for it to sound like a complaint or 'negative' (and LR is my pref as well!).
it feels weird walking by there, like a part of my history is now a parking lot. i don't want to see what they are going to erect in its place...

Add a Comment

Name: Email: URL:
Comment: