City
iPod Touch-es Down in Canada, But Don't Get Your Hopes Up

The iPod Touch is now available in Canada, presenting something approximating the über-hyped iPhone. Some people, however, are confused about how far this approximation really reaches.
Since the iPod Touch's recent release, I've been eager to get my hands on one, as my primary interest in the iPhone wasn't due to its phone or iPod facets, but the potential to have an extremely portable internet device for blogging, using Flickr, and to a lesser extent social networking - which, at a glance, the iPod Touch seemed like it could deliver.
I took a walk into the Eaton's Centre Apple store yesterday to check one out.
Okay, I'll be honest - I was more than just interested in checking one out. I have a MacBook Pro and video iPod, and am not just a happy Apple customer but tend to be an early adopter too. I wanted one and was merely giving myself a little room to be talked out of it.
To my surprise, I was.
It turned out I was misinformed - or misassuming - when it came to the device, although I wasn't quite as lost as the guy beside me who was trying to convince his girlfriend it was a worthwhile purchase.

Her: "Where's the mic," she asked, "like for when you put it to your ear?"
Him: "There's a mic on the earpiece. It's got a sick camera, though!"
Her: "Where?"
(They flip it over, only to see the Apple store alarm sensor.)
Him: "Oh, the sensor's covering it."
Of course, not everyone is going to be quite as let down as that hapless young man, and most comprehend that it's not literally an iPhone. Regardless, the iPod Touch's WiFi capability make it the closest thing to an iPhone to directly hit the Canadian technology market, and Apple fiends like yours truly have still been waking up out of iPhone dreams drooling.
It's important, though, that anyone considering dropping $329 (or $449) on an iPod Touch hoping for a Diet iPhone realizes that they are overestimating.
Adam Schwabe's Nuit Blache liveblogging, via an actual iPhone, is closest to what I envision using such an iContraption for, and as it turns out, the iPod Touch is absolutely not sufficient.
Though it does have a web browser (Safari), there is no direct access whatsoever to the filesystem, so images cannot be uploaded in the standard way via 'Browse' or 'Choose file' buttons, which means no direct uploads to Movable Type, Wordpress or any other such blogging platforms. Flash doesn't work, so forgot about Flickr and Facebook's fancypants uploaders circumnavigating that.
There are peripherals that will let you plug a digital camera's USB cable straight into an iPod and transfer photos to it, which would presumably let you capture photos and get them onto the iPod Touch. However, the only thing you'd be able to do from there is look at them (and tilt them sideways, and zoom with your fingertips, ooh!) and basically nothing else.
Adam's solution, which is what iPhone owners south of the border have had to do so far, was to e-mail the images to Flickr and embed a slideshow in his post until he was able to get home and 'cement' the liveblogging. Facebook also offers the ability to post via e-mail, as do some other sites, but it's certainly not a standard / blanket solution.
And that's the iPhone - the iPod Touch has no mail application whatsoever. It is pretty much a one-way data trap, and anyone hoping to use it for anything beyond that will be faced with an unpleasant restocking fee when they return it.
On top of this, the note-writing application is missing and the calendar can't be edited directly. So, anyone who is letting their imagination fill in the gap between the newest iPod and a portable PDA computer - you're hallucinating.
Unless you're strictly looking for a new iPod for music and video with the occasional ability to check MySpace at Starbucks, put your wallet away. The iPhone has most definitely not Touched down in Canada, no matter what your boyfriend may try to tell you.
Image of old Apple displaying Flickr by ~EvidencE~
Product image from Apple's iPod Touch gallery.


Discussion
14 Comments
Sort By Oldest First / Newest First
Subscribe
The wifi is terrific - I think you're expecting a bit much from this thing out of the gate. The Safari browser is quite useful if you leave aside the no-file-access part... and blogging is quite possible if you use web interfaces for things... Just don't try to do things that the ipod touch can't do... yet. And email is easy. I use gmail's mobile version and it works fine. If you know the web address of an image you can easily incorporate it into a message board post, etc. For the time being there are things this iPod can't do - but the potential is definitely there. I'm very happy with it. Sitting on my front porch checking my email is a new pleasure for me and I can do it while listening to my favourite tunes, or watching Nelvana's "Cosmic Christmas" on the very capable little screen. There are dozens of webapps already written for the iPhone that also work on the Touch as well.
Why people are thinking this is some kind of iPhone lite is beyond me. It's an iPod with a touch interface and wifi.
Pass on this iteration.
Like many people, I used to grab my iPod and cell phone whenever I left the house. The simplicity of just having one device for both functions now is awesome, particularly the way the two integrate together (calls come in over the headphones of the iPhone if you're watching a video or listening to music).
The keyboard is great, but not so great that you won't feel it in your hands after 12 hours of continuous liveblogging and battling with the incessant logons required for Hydro's WiFi service (a password memory feature would be great here).
The touch is a beautiful device as a media player, just don't expect it to do much more than that. Safari is a huge bonus as well as the WiFi, but Apple's really locked down the 'write' data functionality, as you mention.
I'm a fairly technical guy, so I'm more than okay routing around Apple's software updates that will potentially cripple the phone, but for anyone who doesn't know what the terms SSH or FTP are, I wouldn't recommend trying to unlock this thing on your own.
Also, a word to the wise: if you're gonna get one, buy it in the states. it's $30 cheaper, although you will have to add all your extraneous British U's to its dictionary ;)
For an mp3 player, I still ADORE my Creative Zen 30gb video player. It has an awesome drag and drop piece of software, and plays DivX files, meaning most any video I download plays perfectly with no conversions necessary. I've also dropped it not once, not twice, but <i>thrice</i>, really hard, and it still plays without a hitch. Again, to each their own; I HATE iTunes, probably because I have no need to use it otherwise and can't wrap my mind around how non-user friendly it is when compared to a more barebones solution like Winamp.
Lastly, the whole touch screen thing... I don't see the draw of it outside of using it for the web, which I have no desire for, personally. when it comes to entertainment on the go, I have my Zen for music and video, and a DS for some dual screen touch-enabled gaming action. Legend of Zelda: The Phantom Hourglass is EFF-ING-AWE-SOME, and that shit ain't possible on an iPhone.
I've always found the promise of Web 2.0 to be in its ability to let you use technology to interact more with the real world, while up until this point the internet had done so much to keep people locked up inside instead.
and Hamish, without the ability to upload images, blogging is not possible as far as I'm concerned, and I'm talking strictly about MT/WP web-based blogging. Same goes for attachments, yes I could check web-based email (somehow I don't have much faith in Windows Live functioning since it hardly works on an actual computer) but its the ability to send attachments that's lacking, critical for me.
In fact - having migrated from a 5th Gen 60G video iPod - the new device does everything I want it to very well.
The user interface is amazing, the video quality is fine (and much, much brighter than my 5th Gen video iPod), the Wifi iTunes Music Store is a dream to use ...
Even Safari loads well and smoothly.
My own note of disappointment (and this is a minor one, compared to other people's gripes) is that the YouTube feature does not work consistently, but then again, I primarily use my iPod for watching video podcasts (news, etc), and for listening to my music.
One thing I haven't seen anyone else comment on is the new feature that will allow you to sync your Yahoo contact information directly on to your iPod Touch. Convenient, because it will let you edit your contact information on the iPod, and will sync ot with your Yahoo contacts list. (It may do the same with gmail contacts, but I haven't tried it.)
Will I get an iPhone when it is rolled out? Sure, but I don't see Rogers and Apple coming to terms on the data plan issue any time soon. (I have a 100 MB data plan with Rogers for my PDA, and it is $100 a month - either Rogers or Apple will have to bend on their idea of data price plans, and I don't see it happening soon enough to warrant denying myself this significant improvement to the iPod line.)
My final advice? Consider the iPod Touch to be the next evolution to the iPod line, and not a stripped down iPhone. The comparisons cannot be helped, but they do detract from the beauty and simplicity of use that this new device offers.
http://lifehacker.com/software/video-demonstration/manage-a-to+do-list-with-your-ipod-touch-306485.php
http://www.mipsscan.com/2007/10/a-quick-look-at.html