Extra Butter Toronto

Extra Butter

Extra Butter, a new coffee shop in Roncesvalles, has quickly taken over the old Gurts space just south of Geoffrey St. The counter has been pushed all the way to the back, making room for benches and tables and chairs, with plenty of space for the strollers and students in the neighbourhood. Tin and diamond details and salon-style pictures along a rich teal wall offer a loose Art Deco vibe and draw you into the room, but it's the soft cushions and friendly service from owner Cassie Germann that make you want to stay.

Extra Butter Toronto

At the back counter sits the big Nuova Simonelli machine as well as shelves stacked with the bags of Dark City (including the eponymous Extra Butter) beans they use for their coffee and offer for stand-alone purchase. I order an Americano, and the lovely Germann makes one that's thick with crema, imparting the first bitter sip before the chocolate and nuttiness comes through in the full-bodied liquid.

Extra Butter Toronto

They offer the full range of espresso based coffees (espresso, cappuccino, lattes- small $3.25, med $3.75, lrg $4.25) as well as drip in two sizes ($2-2.25). Cream, soy and almond milk are all available. In a genius move, they offer a "Hang Out Special" for $5.00, a drip cup that won't go empty while you're there. The location is nestled beside a David's Tea, and they wisely don't bother to compete with fancy stuff- teas are generic Red Rose, Twinnings and Celestial Seasonings.

Extra Butter Toronto

Germann and another gent Ray, who was baking croissants when I arrived, are familiar faces on the street -- both worked at Cherry Bomb -- and there a few carryover traits from that neighbourhood stalwart, including the smell of fresh baked goods spread throughout the room. You see can see trays of them behind the counter and through the pass into a baking kitchen.

Extra Butter Toronto

They make their cheese ($3.00) and chocolate ($2.75) croissants, cookies (some vegan) at $2.00 each and a maple mustard bacon bun ($4.00) for a heartier, meatier affair, and sandwiches and other baked goods are expected in the near future.

Extra Butter Toronto

The shop opened on March 12th and already lots of enthusiastic people were typing away on computers, sucking up the free Wi-Fi, and asking questions to the bubbly Germann when I paid my visit. I expect full tanning to happen on the front bench once spring finally gives way, giving customers that sheen of Extra Butter.

Extra Butter Toronto

Photos by Andrew Williamson


Extra Butter

Leaflet | © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Improve this map

Join the conversation Load comments

Extra Butter

Latest Reviews

The Alternative Cafe

Republic

El Almacen

Cherry Bomb

The Place

Black Gold Cafe